After the invitation of the Korean president’s wife .. Is it permissible to eat dog meat in Islam?

Kim Geun-hee, the wife of South Korean President Yoon Seok-yeol, has called for giving up dog meat, saying only South Korea and China are among the economically large countries where it is allowed.

“I look forward to concrete achievements regarding animal violence, the neglect of abandoned animals and the eating of dog meat during the term of President Yoon’s government,” Kim said in an interview with the Seoul Daily.

“I believe that global culture should be shared with developed countries. Eating dog meat can leave negative feelings towards Korea and dog meat is not good for health. Dogs often grow up to eat in tight cages and they were antibiotics are also given. ” she added.

“Ultimately, refusing to eat dog meat means expressing human respect for animal-friendly animals and the value of life,” she said.

On the issue of passing a law to end canine eating, the wife of the South Korean president said: “I think it can be resolved politically, as is the way to provide support to small food companies for transform their type of business “.

The first press conference was held with Kim on the topic of animal rights protection.

Known as an animal lover, Kim has raised 4 dogs and 3 cats and has supported organizations to rescue abandoned animals for a long time.

Islamic Research: Eating dog and cat meat is not legally allowed

The Fatwa Commission of the Islamic Research Academy said that eating the meat of dogs and cats is not allowed under Islamic law, which is confirmed by the words of the Messenger of God, peace and blessings of Allaah be upon him: “Eating any animal with fanta is forbidden. ”

And the commission added, in a statement today, Wednesday: “What was mentioned in Sahih Muslim that the Messenger of God – praise and peace be upon him -” forbids the eating of all carnivores with mushrooms … “, and includes all those with mushrooms: dog and cat, ie: (cat). As narrated by Tirmidhi and Abu Dawud from the hadith of Jabir – may Allah be pleased with him – and others who said: peace be upon him – he stopped eating cats … ”(cat).

Based on this legal root, the commission confirmed that what was recently raised regarding the permissibility of eating dog and cat meat attributed to Maliki’s school of thought is wrong. the chapter on the prohibition of eating all wild animals and the commission continued: Imam Malik said: This is the work with us – that is, the people of Medina – and this is the most accurate saying because of the power of the testimony and its approval. of the public, and accordingly: it is forbidden to eat dog meat Cats, and what is attributed to the doctrine of the Maliki gentlemen regarding the permissibility of eating is incorrect.

The Fatwa Committee of the Islamic Research Academy added in its statement: “Regarding what was released by Sheikh Abdul Hamid Al-Atrash, on one of the satellite channels, that it is permissible to eat the meat of dogs and cats, it is an opinion of inaccurate and does not represent the opinion of Al-Azhar Al-Sharif. ”

The complex warned all media that this sheikh has nothing to do with the Fatwa Committee and that those he issues controversial opinions express only himself and his personal opinion.

For his part, Dr. Ahmed Karima, a professor of Islamic law at Al-Azhar Al-Sharif, confirmed the ban on eating dog and cat meat, asking: How is it permissible to eat dog meat? The Prophet (peace and blessings of Allaah be upon him) decreed that the dog’s saliva was impure, so he said, “If a dog drinks from one of you’s vessels, let him wash it seven times.” Most jurists, with the exception of the Malikis, went to the filth of the whole dog and that his passing in front of the hat interrupts the prayer and that sound reason makes the natural Muslim indignant about this. An action contrary to the human nature of the Muslim . .

Karima said Al-Atrash’s reasoning about his permission to eat cats and dogs is not appropriate, so eating “lizard” does not mean that cats and dogs are allowed to eat, and lizards are an animal. of the rabbit-like desert, alive. in the desert, and Mecca was not accustomed to it, so the Prophet, peace be upon him, refused to eat it because it is an animal. The tribe of Mecca did not know him at that time.

And he continued: “As for the dog, he is evil, legally and usually, and enters into the decision of the saying of the Almighty:” And He permits you good and forbids you evil. ” As for the claim that some of the Malikis said it is permissible, we are referring only to worship and that which relates to legal texts in human beings.

For his part, Dr. Abbas Shoman, Secretary General of the Council of Senior Scholars, said: “One of the issues that arises from time to time and does not need to be raised because of the useless social noise is the issue of eating the meat of cats and dogs and the like. , as happened recently on one of the satellite channels. Eat these animals.

The former agent of Al-Azhar, through his page on the social network “Facebook”, added that their statement that there is no prohibition except in text, and since these things are not mentioned in the Book of God, so based on the permissibility of them, he replied that the text on their prohibition is present, which is his saying, sallallaahu ‘alayhi wa sallam. The Messenger of God, peace and blessings of God be upon him, said: It is forbidden to eat any animal with a bandage.

Shoman stressed that the permissibility of eating cats and dogs and the like is based on the opinion of Maliki’s school of thought and some of its ancestors, so it has been rejected, that on the other hand, there is the opinion of most jurists who say it is forbidden to they are eaten, which is correct in the Maliki school itself, and as narrated by Imam Malik himself after mentioning the hadith of prohibition on his page. three thoughts: prohibition, disapproval and admissibility.

Al-Atrash: It is permissible to eat or kill cats and dogs

Dr. Abdel Hamid al-Atrash, the former head of the Fatwa Committee in Al-Azhar, had said that it was permissible to eat or kill cats and dogs, noting that “such a topic had previously been presented to the Fatwa Committee and was allowed. “, He said.

Al-Atrash said in a telephone interview with the public opinion program, Amr Abdel Hamid, that “The Prophet commanded us to have mercy on animals, people and birds, and he said:” If you kill, then do good to the killers, and one of you let him sharpen his blade and let his sacrifice cease) ”, and religion also showed that a woman entered the fire with a cat. .

Al-Atrash added that “there is a legal rule for Imam Malik. I have nothing wrong with eating dogs or cats, so eating dogs or cats is allowed, but after the recommendation.”

After the presenter of the program, Amr Abdel Hamid, asked him: “Is it forbidden to eat cats and dogs?” He replied: “There is no prohibition except with text and there is no text in it,” he said.

Al-Atrash noted that “the export of dogs and cats is permissible as long as state laws agree to it.”

Leave a Comment